The P/E ratio, explained with two cafés
Here's a question that catches almost every beginner. Two café chains are listed on the stock market. Chain A's shares cost €100. Chain B's shares cost €120. Which one is cheaper?
If you said Chain A, you're in good company, and you're probably wrong. A share price on its own tells you almost nothing. What matters is what you get for it.
Price is only half the sentence
When you buy one share, you buy a small slice of the company's profit. So the useful question isn't "how much does a share cost?" It's "how much am I paying for each euro the company earns?"
That's what the price-to-earnings ratio, usually written P/E, measures.
P/E = share price ÷ yearly profit per share
Profit per share is the company's profit over the last twelve months, divided by the number of shares. Companies publish it in their annual and quarterly reports, and most finance websites show it next to the price.
Back to the cafés
| Chain A | Chain B | |
|---|---|---|
| Share price | €100 | €120 |
| Yearly profit per share | €4 | €8 |
| P/E | 25 | 15 |
| You pay for €1 of yearly profit | €25 | €15 |
Chain B's share costs more, but each share comes with twice the profit. You pay €15 for every euro Chain B earns, against €25 at Chain A. For what you actually get, Chain B is the cheaper share.
You can also flip the ratio. One divided by the P/E gives the earnings yield: 4% for Chain A and about 6.7% for Chain B. That's the profit you buy with each euro you invest, a bit like comparing interest rates.
So why would anyone pay more?
A high P/E isn't a mistake. It usually means investors expect profits to grow. If Chain A is opening a new café every week and its profit is set to double, paying €25 today could turn out to be reasonable. If that growth stalls, the high price has nothing left to hold it up.
A low P/E has its own trap. Sometimes a share looks cheap because investors expect trouble: a big customer leaving, prices falling, or a one-off gain that flattered last year's profit. Cheap and good value are not the same thing.
Three questions to ask every time
- Compared with what? A P/E means more next to similar companies in the same industry than next to a random number.
- Why is it high or low? Look for the story: faster growth, a stronger brand, more debt, or a problem.
- Will the profit hold? The ratio uses last year's profit. You are buying future profit.
One more limit: if a company makes no profit, it has no meaningful P/E at all. To judge those, you need sales, cash and debt. That's Part 1, and the free preview on growth and profit.
Quick check
Stock X costs €50 and earns €2 per share each year. Stock Y costs €30 and earns €3 per share. Which has the lower P/E?
This is a free preview of Part 2: Price versus value
It comes from Practice Before You Invest, the StockPlay ebook. The full part takes this idea further, with more worked examples and a checklist you can reuse. Five parts, one price: €7.